Smoothing Settings on Newton and Average Speed
Posted: Tue Apr 23, 2013 4:50 pm
Since the latest Newton firmware upgrade, I have noticed that the Newton reports a lower Average Speed then my Garmin Edge 500. Both devices are measuring distance and cadence using a gsc-10 and both have wheel size set to 2096mm. Newton was set to a smoothing of 5 and the Edge has autopause set to 2.4 mph.
I did a pure out and back ride on Sunday and compared the Newton and the Edge at ride completion. The Edge showed 41.6 miles and 16.2 mph. The Newton showed 40.8 miles and 16.0 mph. Isaac reported the Newton ride file with 41.6 miles and 16.2 mph.
I switched the smoothing on the Newton from 5 to 2. On today's ride, I photographed the Newton and Edge on my bike at ride end. See attached photo.
The Newton reported 16.0 mph and the Edge reported 16.2 mph after 76.7 miles. Isaac reports 16.2 mph (as does SportTracks and Strava).
I am wondering if the Newton is applying smoothing to average speed which would be a bug IMHO. With smoothing = 2 the error is decreased compared to smoothing = 5 but still obvious.
I did a pure out and back ride on Sunday and compared the Newton and the Edge at ride completion. The Edge showed 41.6 miles and 16.2 mph. The Newton showed 40.8 miles and 16.0 mph. Isaac reported the Newton ride file with 41.6 miles and 16.2 mph.
I switched the smoothing on the Newton from 5 to 2. On today's ride, I photographed the Newton and Edge on my bike at ride end. See attached photo.
The Newton reported 16.0 mph and the Edge reported 16.2 mph after 76.7 miles. Isaac reports 16.2 mph (as does SportTracks and Strava).
I am wondering if the Newton is applying smoothing to average speed which would be a bug IMHO. With smoothing = 2 the error is decreased compared to smoothing = 5 but still obvious.